Williams College · Williamstown, MA
The Williams Business Review

Macroeconomy · Business · Markets

Macroeconomy

The U.S. Government is Now an Investor. Should It Be?

Washington now holds a stake in more than 40 companies. Classical economists are skeptical, markets are uncertain, but the precedent seems here to stay.

Weston Chance· Staff Writer· November 16, 2026
The U.S. Government is Now an Investor. Should It Be?

In August 2025, Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick rolled out a new economic doctrine; in it, he asserts that “we should get an equity stake for our money.” Days later, the federal government converted $8.9 billion in unpaid CHIPS Act and Secure Enclave grants into 433.3 million shares of Intel at $20.47 apiece. The resulting 9.9 percent stake made Washington the chipmaker's largest shareholder. Fifteen months on, the Cato Institute counts some form of federal equity position in 41 companies, up from 14 at the beginning of this calendar year. The catalog runs from rare-earth mining to quantum-computing, concentrating on strategic industries on the premise that the taxpayer should share in the upside of subsidized companies.

For a country that has so passionately championed the free market and long defined itself against state capitalism, this is a seemingly remarkable turn. It is not, however, unprecedented – at least not completely.

State-owned enterprises and sovereign wealth funds are often met with staunch resistance by the American public despite their growing popularity overseas, but still, government control of companies is not a purely foreign concept to the United States. The federal government owned a fifth of Alexander Hamilton’s First Bank of the United States; during the Depression, the Reconstruction Finance Corporation bought preferred stock in thousands of banks; and since the 2008 crash, companies like Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac still operate under conservatorship.

In each of these previous forays into American state capitalism, the arrangements were the direct result of economic or geopolitical turmoil and in many cases were sold off at earliest convenience. Today’s maneuvers differ in a couple key ways – first and foremost in their framing. Most of these companies were not failing in any real sense, so the decision to intervene was not to provide stability but rather to tactically unlock fundamental value in specific spaces.

In many ways, this was a direct counter to China’s growing supply-chain and technological dominance. The selection of investments reinforces this notion; rare earth minerals, mining, quantum computing, chipmakers, energy, and defense were the key targets. The administration is aiming to build national resilience in sectors that could become mission critical to national security and the global artificial intelligence race.

Washington has subsidized strategic industries for decades through various mechanism, but this recent action points toward a far more aggressive posture. Take MP Materials for example. They are the only vertically integrated “mine to magnet” company in the U.S. Rather than just inject cash, the Pentagon purchased $400 million of preferred stock plus warrants that together convert to about 15 percent of the company. They also set a ten-year price floor for the specific rare-earth oxides MP Materials produces – essentially positioning themselves as both an owner and an insurer. Other investment tools include converted grants, equity tied to loans, and special veto powers called “golden shares.” These are not entirely novel concepts in America, but again, the context appears to be markedly different.

Another interesting distinction comes with the legality of these actions; almost every previous stake was taken out in an emergency under explicit congressional approval. Today, much of the legal authority is inferred rather than granted, leaving the government vulnerable to litigation.

Just eight months ago, Intel shareholder Richard Paisner sued the company’s board and the Commerce Department in Delaware, arguing that the CHIPS Act never authorized turning grants into equity, and that the Board gave away nearly 10 percent of the company for no real value. The DOJ has invoked sovereign immunity in response and filed for the case to be dismissed, but it remains pending in district court. A non-partisan Lawfare analysis recently concluded that several of the Pentagon’s stakes are likely unlawful, further calling the situation into question.

Many free-market economists and libertarian leaning politicians have sharply criticized Lutnick and his decisions. Senator Rand Paul (R-KY) suggested that if socialism is the government owning the factors of production, then the government taking a stake in Intel is a step toward socialism. Other critics see a conflict-of-interest issue – the Department of Commerce sets export rules for chips while wielding a 10 percent stake in Intel. Independent investors also worry about dilution and misalignment with shareholder interest.

While the policy has drawn scrutiny from several parties, many have come to the government’s defense, believing federal investment to be a legitimate mechanism for national growth and a positive development for taxpayers. Lutnick frames it as a simple question of fairness: if taxpayers fund a company’s comeback, should they not get to share in the profits? Senator Bernie Sanders (D-VT), rarely a Trump ally, strongly agrees. He argues the public has the right to “a reasonable return” on its subsidies. Others close to the White House see this as the groundwork of a sovereign wealth fund like Norway’s. Across the aisle, many progressives believe that as a shareholder, the government can use its voting power to keep corporations accountable.

In just about fifteen months, strong opinions have emerged all over the political, financial, and public spheres regarding the future of these holdings. In the markets, many of the public companies that received government support have retreated over the last several months after a strong initial pop. Intel stock specifically has experienced extreme volatility, surging nearly 600 percent before losing over half of its market cap since June. Even so, its price has nearly tripled since the U.S. government secured its position in 2025.

Interestingly, Senator Jon Husted (R-OH) proposed one of the few pieces of legislation gaining traction in this arena: a bill requiring the government to sell the stakes and use the gains pay down the national debt. This highlights the murky nature of the divide. There does not seem to be a clear partisan stance on the matter – a rare sight for Washington today.

For this reason, it seems highly unlikely much will change regarding the investments while Trump is still in office. As for 2029, the next president will face a tough decision: unwind an ambitious experiment, or keep a portfolio, that for all its flaws, has made taxpayers money. While certainly a tough call, history tends to suggest that once the government owns something powerful, they rarely let it go.